| MS | New York City FC | 1 | 3 | Charlotte FC |
| New York City FC | Charlotte FC | |
| 1 Sean Johnson | 1 Kristijan Kahlina | |
| 3 Anton Tinnerholm | 2 Jan Sobocinski | |
| 4 Maxime Chanot | 5 Anton Walkes | |
| 5 Thiago Martins | 22 Christian Fuchs | |
| 12 Malte Amundsen | 24 Jaylin Lindsey | |
| 7 Alfredo Morales | 13 Brandt Bronico | |
| 8 Thiago | 20 Derrick Jones | |
| 10 Maxi Moralez | 35 Quinn McNeill | |
| 20 Santiago Rodriguez | 11 Karol Swiderski | |
| 43 Talles Magno | 17 Orrin McKinze Gaines | |
| 9 Heber | 18 Kerwin Vargas | |
| Yedekler | Yedekler | |
| 2 Chris Gloster | 7 Kamil Jozwiak | |
| 13 Luis Barraza | 8 Jordy Alcivar | |
| 21 Andres Jasson | 12 Daniel Rios | |
| 22 | 15 Ben Bender | |
| 23 Gedion Zelalem | 16 Andre Shinyashiki | |
| 26 Nicolas Acevedo | 25 Harrison Afful | |
| 32 Vuk Latinovich | 26 Yordy Reyna | |
| 38 Gabriel Pereira | 28 Joseph Mora | |
| 80 Justin Haak | 31 George Marks |
