| MS | New York City FC | 1 | 3 | Charlotte FC |
| New York City FC | Charlotte FC | |
| ' | Orrin McKinze Gaines | |
| ' | Karol Swiderski | |
| ' | Karol Swiderski | |
| Alfredo Morales | ' | |
| Maxime Chanot | ' | |
| Alfredo Morales | ' | |
| Justin Haak | ' | |
| ' | Quinn McNeill | |
| ' | Kerwin Vargas | |
| ' | Kamil Jozwiak | |
| ' | Quinn McNeill | |
| ' | Ben Bender | |
| ' | Karol Swiderski | |
| ' | Brandt Bronico | |
| ' | Karol Swiderski | |
| ' | Andre Shinyashiki | |
| Thiago | ' | |
| Gabriel Pereira | ' | |
| Malte Amundsen | ' | |
| Chris Gloster | ' | |
| ' | Christian Fuchs | |
| ' | Orrin McKinze Gaines | |
| ' | Harrison Afful |
