| MS | West Ham United | 3 | 0 | Sheffield United |
| West Ham United | Sheffield United | |
| 1 Lukasz Fabianski | 1 Aaron Ramsdale | |
| 3 Aaron Cresswell | 6 Chris Basham | |
| 15 Craig Dawson | 12 John Egan | |
| 23 Issa Diop | 22 Ethan Ampadu | |
| 5 Vladimír Coufal | 3 Enda Stevens | |
| 10 Manuel Lanzini | 7 John Lundstram | |
| 11 Jesse Lingard | 16 Oliver Norwood | |
| 28 Tomás Soucek | 20 Jayden Bogle | |
| 31 Benjamin Johnson | 23 Ben Osborn | |
| 41 Declan Rice | 10 Billy Sharp | |
| 20 Jarrod Bowen | 17 David McGoldrick | |
| Yedekler | Yedekler | |
| 9 Mohamed Saïd Benrahma | 2 George Baldock | |
| 14 Frederik Alves Ibsen | 9 Oliver McBurnie | |
| 16 Mark Noble | 13 Max Lowe | |
| 18 Pablo Fornals Malla | 14 Oliver Burke | |
| 24 Ryan Fredericks | 15 Phil Jagielka | |
| 25 David Edward Martin | 18 Wesley Foderingham | |
| 45 Ademipo Ibrahim Odubeko | 24 Rhian Brewster | |
| 54 Conor Coventry | 29 Kean Bryan | |
| 75 Jamal Baptiste | 35 Frankie Maguire |
