| MS | Sunderland | 1 | 3 | Lincoln City |
| Sunderland | Lincoln City | |
| ' | Christopher Maguire | |
| ' | Teddy Bishop | |
| ' | Christopher Maguire | |
| Carl Winchester | ' | |
| ' | Timothy Eyoma | |
| Carl Winchester | ' | |
| ' | Christopher Maguire | |
| ' | Teddy Bishop | |
| ' | Max Melbourne | |
| ' | Morgan Whittaker | |
| Jack Diamond | ' | |
| Aiden O'Brien | ' | |
| Dennis Cirkin | ' | |
| Denver Hume | ' | |
| Ross Stewart | ' | |
| Ross Stewart | ' | |
| ' | Hakeeb Adelakun | |
| ' | Christopher Maguire | |
| ' | Hakeeb Adelakun | |
| ' | Lasse Soerensen | |
| Alex Pritchard | ' | |
| Josh Hawkes | ' | |
| ' | Lewis Fiorini | |
| ' | Morgan Whittaker | |
| ' | Jamie Robson | |
| Elliot Embleton | ' | |
| ' | Lasse Soerensen | |
| ' | Conor McGrandles | |
| Callum Doyle | ' |
