| MS | Schalke 04 | 1 | 0 | Mainz 05 |
| Schalke 04 | Mainz 05 | |
| Simon Terodde | ' | |
| Florent Mollet | ' | |
| ' | Alexander Hack | |
| ' | Stefan Bell | |
| Florent Mollet | ' | |
| Dominick Drexler | ' | |
| ' | Jae-Sung Lee | |
| ' | Jonathan Burkardt | |
| Maya Yoshida | ' | |
| ' | Aaron Caricol | |
| ' | Angelo Fulgini | |
| ' | Edimilson Fernandes | |
| Kenan Karaman | ' | |
| Kenan Karaman | ' | |
| Danny Latza | ' | |
| ' | Danny da Costa | |
| ' | Silvan Widmer | |
| ' | Marcus Ingvartsen | |
| ' | Leandro Barreiro | |
| Simon Terodde | ' | |
| Sebastian Polter | ' | |
| Cedric Brunner | ' | |
| Mehmet Aydin | ' |
