| MS | Oldham Athletic | 3 | 3 | Crawley Town |
| Oldham Athletic | Crawley Town | |
| Jack Stobbs | ' | |
| Harry Vaughan | ' | |
| Hallam Hope | ' | |
| Davis Keillor-Dunn | ' | |
| ' | Ashley Nadesan | |
| ' | George Francomb | |
| ' | Ashley Nadesan | |
| ' | James Tilley | |
| Harry Vaughan | ' | |
| Junior Luamba | ' | |
| ' | Will Ferry | |
| Jordan Clarke | ' | |
| Christopher Missilou | ' | |
| ' | Archie Davies | |
| ' | Aramide Oteh | |
| Jack Stobbs | ' | |
| Isaac Modi | ' | |
| ' | Aramide Oteh | |
| Davis Keillor-Dunn | ' | |
| Nicky Adams | ' | |
| ' | James Tilley | |
| ' | Florian Kastrati |
