| MS | Luton Town | 1 | 3 | Sheffield United |
| Luton Town | Sheffield United | |
| ' | Rhys Norrington-Davies | |
| ' | Max Lowe | |
| ' | Mason Holgate | |
| ' | Gustavo Hamer | |
| ' | Max Lowe | |
| ' | Cameron Archer | |
| ' | James McAtee | |
| Carlton Morris | ' | |
| Carlton Morris | ' | |
| Jordan Clark | ' | |
| Tahith Chong | ' | |
| ' | Gustavo Hamer | |
| ' | Tom Davies | |
| Reece Burke | ' | |
| Andros Townsend | ' | |
| ' | Ben Osborn | |
| ' | Vinicius de Souza Costa | |
| ' | Cameron Archer | |
| ' | Rhian Brewster | |
| ' | James McAtee | |
| ' | Oliver Norwood | |
| Carlton Morris | ' | |
| Cauley Woodrow | ' | |
| Alfie Doughty | ' | |
| Luke Berry | ' |
