| MS | Columbus Crew | 2 | 2 | Atlanta United |
| Columbus Crew | Atlanta United | |
| 1 Eloy Room | 34 Rocco Rios Novo | |
| 4 Jonathan Mensah | 6 Alan Franco | |
| 5 Milos Degenek | 11 Brooks Lennon | |
| 7 Pedro Santos | 15 Andrew Gutman | |
| 31 Steven Moreira | 22 Juan Jose Purata | |
| 6 Darlington Nagbe | 5 Santiago Sosa | |
| 8 Artur | 8 Thiago Almada | |
| 10 Lucas Zelarayan | 13 Amar Sejdic | |
| 12 Luis Diaz | 19 Luiz Araujo | |
| 22 Derrick Etienne | 26 Caleb Wiley | |
| 9 Juan Hernandez | 29 Ronaldo Cisneros | |
| Yedekler | Yedekler | |
| 3 Josh Williams | 2 Ronald Hernandez | |
| 13 Kevin Molino | 4 Dominic Dwyer | |
| 14 Yaw Yeboah | 7 Josef Martinez | |
| 17 Marlon Hairston | 10 Marcelino Moreno | |
| 19 Erik Hurtado | 14 Franco Ibarra | |
| 21 Aidan Morris | 21 Edwin Mosquera | |
| 24 Evan Bush | 23 Raul Gudino | |
| 26 James Igbekeme | 30 Machop Chol | |
| 30 Will Sands | 32 George Campbell |
