| MS | Columbus Crew | 2 | 2 | Atlanta United |
| Columbus Crew | Atlanta United | |
| ' | Caleb Wiley | |
| ' | Santiago Sosa | |
| Pedro Santos | ' | |
| Will Sands | ' | |
| Artur | ' | |
| Derrick Etienne | ' | |
| Derrick Etienne | ' | |
| Kevin Molino | ' | |
| Luis Diaz | ' | |
| Juan Hernandez | ' | |
| ' | Santiago Sosa | |
| ' | Amar Sejdic | |
| ' | Franco Ibarra | |
| ' | Caleb Wiley | |
| ' | Edwin Mosquera | |
| Will Sands | ' | |
| Juan Hernandez | ' | |
| ' | Luiz Araujo | |
| ' | Dominic Dwyer | |
| ' | Ronaldo Cisneros | |
| ' | Josef Martinez | |
| ' | Juan Jose Purata | |
| ' | Edwin Mosquera | |
| ' | Edwin Mosquera | |
| Jonathan Mensah | ' | |
| Steven Moreira | ' | |
| Marlon Hairston | ' | |
| Artur | ' | |
| Aidan Morris | ' | |
| Luis Diaz | ' | |
| Josh Williams | ' |
